Commodities · Managing commodity risk · lesson 8 of 9 · 7 min read · David Alexander
Margin calls, and the exit you did not choose
stop-out
The broker's forced closure of a position when account equity falls below a set fraction of required margin. It executes at the market's price, at the market's moment, with no reference to any plan - the position's worst-case exit, chosen by arithmetic rather than judgement.
Module 3 established that margin is not a cost. This lesson is about the day it becomes something else: the trigger for an exit you did not choose.
The machinery, briefly
Equity is balance plus open profit and loss, marked continuously. When it falls to the broker's margin-call level, the demand arrives: add funds or reduce. At the stop-out level below it, the broker stops asking. The position closes at market, in whatever liquidity that moment offers - and lesson 4 taught you which moments offer least. A stop-out during a report gap is the worst execution this platform can describe, and it is precisely when stop-outs cluster.
Why commodities reach it faster
Work the example: the moves that trigger the call and the forced close are single-digit percentages of the commodity's price. Module 6's arithmetic - effective leverage times daily range - says days that size are ordinary here. An account that would survive months of an index position's wandering can meet a commodity stop-out in a week, holding a position whose owner believed the margin requirement was the risk.
The stop-out is a symptom
- A properly sized position - lessons 2 and 5 - keeps losses inside a budget the account can absorb; equity never approaches the call.
- Meeting a margin call therefore means the sizing was wrong at entry, whatever else went wrong after.
- The response to one is not a deposit. Topping up defends a position that has already proven it was too large - doubling the stake on the same mistake.
Read the worked example as a post-mortem, not a procedure: every number in it was knowable at entry. The trader who computes them before the trade never meets the broker's version of risk management - which is the entire point of this module.
Worked example
figures in USDA $12,000 US dollar account holding one WTI contract ($80,000 notional) at 10:1. Illustrative figures.
- One WTI contract is $80,000 of exposure. At 10:1, the margin held against it is $8,000 - most of this account's $12,000.
- A move of 5.00% against the position brings the margin call; 10.00% brings the forced close. On a commodity, module 6's arithmetic says those are ordinary days, not disasters.
- At the stop-out, $8,000 is gone - a loss no plan chose, at a price no plan set. The margin call is not a safety net. It is what risk management looks like when the broker has to do it for you.
Check your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does receiving a margin call reveal?