Indices · What trading indices costs · lesson 1 of 9 · 6 min read · David Alexander
The wrapper decides the cost
wrapper
The contract through which an index is actually traded - a cash CFD, a futures contract, a spread bet, an ETF. The index has no cost, because nobody holds it. Every cost you pay is a property of the wrapper, and the same index costs materially different amounts depending on which one you chose.
Module 1 established that an index is a calculation and that everything tradeable carrying its name is a separate contract. This module is the bill for that fact.
The index costs nothing
There is no spread on a calculation, no financing on a measurement, no commission on a number. Every charge in this module attaches to a contract someone wrote.
Which is why "what does it cost to trade the FTSE" has no answer until you say through what.
Where each wrapper puts its costs
- Cash CFD: a spread on entry, and financing every night you hold it.
- Future: a spread, a commission, exchange fees, and no nightly charge - the financing is already inside the price.
- Spread bet: a spread, financing on daily bets, and a different tax treatment that is outside this module's scope.
- ETF: a spread, a management fee, and the fund's own internal costs.
Four vehicles, one index, and no two of them charge in the same places.
Why comparison tables mislead
A comparison quoting one number per vehicle has to pick a holding period, and it usually does not say which one it picked.
The cheapest vehicle for a position held four hours is not the cheapest for one held four months, and it is not a close call - the ranking inverts. Lesson 8 works out exactly where.
What this module does and does not cover
It covers what each cost is, where it lands, and how to add them up for a specific position and holding period.
It does not compare the wrappers exhaustively - that is module 8, which has the basis and the tracking differences to do it properly. And full futures roll mechanics belong to the futures track, not here.
Check your understanding
Question 1 of 2
Why does "what does it cost to trade this index" have no answer as asked?